Republicanism

Republicanism is the view that a republic is the best form of government.

Anti-monarchial republicanism

One meaning of republicanism is the opposition to monarchies. Republic comes from the Latin word res publica and one meaning of this term is the form of government that began with the overthrow of the last tyrant known as the Roman Republic. While this government was much lauded by its contemporaries, once it was replaced with the empire, republicanism became all but nonexistent throughout Europe for several centuries. Outside of Europe, opposition to monarchy before the modern period is not generally termed republicanism. Islam, for instance, is opposed to monarchies seeing the ideal state as one where the ummah, caliph, and sharia all play a role in governance. This concept shares some of the same classical roots as European republicanism and in modern times this form of government is called "republican" in English, but in pre-modern times it is not generally called republicanism.

Related Topics:
Res publica - Roman Republic - Islam - Ummah - Caliph - Sharia

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Early History

In Europe republicanism was revived in the late Middle Ages when a number of small states embraced republican systems of government. These were generally small, but wealthy, trading states in which the merchant class had risen to prominence. Haakonssen notes that by the Renaissance Europe was divided with those states controlled by a landed elite being monarchies and those controlled by a commercial elite being republics. These included Italian city states like Florence and Venice and the members of the Hanseatic League.

Related Topics:
Middle Ages - Florence - Venice - Hanseatic League

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

At this period the school of thought known as classical republicanism or civic humanism came into being outlining how best to run a republic. These authors, most prominent among them being Niccolò Machiavelli, based republicanism on the states of the classical world, such as Athens, Sparta, and the Roman Republic as well as the ancient works of political philosophy such as Aristotle, Polybius and especially Cicero. In the Renaissance the classical states were dubbed republics, and are today still sometimes referred to as classical republics.

Related Topics:
Classical republicanism - Civic humanism - Niccolò Machiavelli - Athens - Sparta - Roman Republic - Aristotle - Polybius - Cicero - Classical republic

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

While many Renaissance authors spoke highly of republics they were rarely critical of monarchies. While Machiavelli's Discourses on Livy is the period's key work on republics he also wrote The Prince on how to best run a monarchy. One cause of this was that the early modern writers did not see the republican model as one that could be applied universally, most felt that it could only be successful in very small and highly urbanized city-states.

Related Topics:
Discourses on Livy - The Prince

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Anti-monarchism became far more strident in the Dutch Republic during and after the Eighty Years' War. This anti-monarchism was less political philosophy and more propagandizing with most of the anti-monarchist works appearing in the form of widely distributed pamphlets. Over time this evolved into a systematic critique of monarchies written by men such as Johan Uytenhage de Mist, Radboud Herman Scheel, Lieven de Beaufort and the brothers Johan and Peter de la Court. These writers saw all monarchies as illegitimate tyrannies that were inherently corrupt. Less an attack on their former overlords these works were more concerned with preventing the position of Stadholder from evolving into a monarchy. This Dutch republicanism also had an important influence on French Huguenots during the Wars of Religion.

Related Topics:
Dutch Republic - Eighty Years' War - Pamphlet - Johan Uytenhage de Mist - Radboud Herman Scheel - Lieven de Beaufort - Johan - Peter de la Court - Stadholder - Huguenots - Wars of Religion

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

In the other states of early modern Europe republicanism was more moderate. In England a republicanism evolved that was not wholly opposed to monarchy, but rather thinkers such as Thomas More and John Milton saw an monarchy firmly constrained by law as compatible with republicanism. The small minority that was actively opposed to all monarchy was largely discredited by the regicide of Charles I and later republicans strove to distance themselves from that act.

Related Topics:
Thomas More - John Milton - Regicide - Charles I

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

In Poland moderate republicanism was also an important ideology. In Poland republicans were those who supported the status quo of having a very weak monarch and opposed those who felt a stronger monarchy was needed. These Polish republicans such as Lukasz Gornicki, Andrzej Wolan, and Stanislaw Konarski were well read in classical and Renaissance texts and firmly believed that their state was a Republic on the Roman model and called their state the Rzeczpospolita. Unlike in the other areas Polish republicanism was not the ideology of the commercial, but rather of the landed aristocracy who would be the ones to lose power if the monarchy was expanded.

Related Topics:
Poland - Lukasz Gornicki - Andrzej Wolan - Stanislaw Konarski - Rzeczpospolita

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

In the Enlightenment anti-monarchism stopped being coextensive with the civic humanism of the Renaissance. Classical republicanism, still supported by philosophers such as Rousseau and Montesquieu, became just one of a number of ideologies opposed to monarchy. The newer forms of anti-monarchism such as liberalism and later socialism quickly overtook classical republicanism as the leading republican ideologies. Republicanism also became far more widespread and monarchies began to be challenged throughout Europe.

Related Topics:
Rousseau - Montesquieu - Liberalism - Socialism

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Modern History

Anti-monarchial republicanism remains an important political force in many states especially in the Commonwealth nations such as Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Jamaica and Barbados. In these countries, republicanism is largely about the post-colonial evolution of their relationships with the United Kingdom.

Related Topics:
Commonwealth - Australia - Canada - New Zealand - Jamaica - Barbados

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

In the surviving European monarchies, such as the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and Sweden there has not been much contemporary popular support for republicanism, though in most cases it nonetheless commands a significant minority position. In such states republicanism is usually motivated by decreasing popularity of the Royal Family, who may be increasingly embroiled in scandal or conflict. However the classical argument against monarchy versus the egalitarian aspects of republicanism will often remain prominent as well.

Related Topics:
United Kingdom - The Netherlands - Sweden - Royal Family

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

See also: Abolished monarchy, Australian republicanism, Australian Republican Movement, British republicanism, British republican movement, Irish republicanism, Canadian republicanism, Citizens for a Canadian Republic, Republicanism in New Zealand, Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand

Related Topics:
Abolished monarchy - Australian republicanism - Australian Republican Movement - British republicanism - British republican movement - Irish republicanism - Canadian republicanism - Citizens for a Canadian Republic - Republicanism in New Zealand - Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~