Karl Marx
:This article is about the German political philosopher Karl Marx, for other uses of Marx, see Marx (disambiguation)
Biography
Early life
Karl Marx was born into a progressive and wealthy Jewish family in Prussian Trier, Germany. His father Herschel, descending from a long line of rabbis, was a lawyer and Herschel's brother Samuel was—like many of his ancestors—chief rabbi of Trier. In 1817, before Karl's birth, Herschel Marx converted to the Prussian state religion of Lutheranism to keep his position as a lawyer, which he had gained under the Napoleonic regime. The Marx family was very liberal and the Marx household hosted many visiting intellectuals and artists during Karl's early life.
Related Topics:
Jew - Prussia - Trier - Germany - Rabbi - State religion - Lutheranism - Napoleon - Liberal
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Education
Marx received good marks in gymnasium, the Prussian secondary education school. His senior thesis, which anticipated his later development of a social analysis of religion, was a treatise entitled "Religion: The Glue That Binds Society Together", for which he won a prize.
Related Topics:
Gymnasium - Secondary education
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
In 1833 Marx enrolled in the University of Bonn to study law, at his father's behest. He joined the Trier Tavern Club and at one point served as its president; his grades suffered as he spent most of his time singing songs in beer halls (McLellen 17). The following year, his father forced him to transfer to the far more serious and academically oriented Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität in Berlin (now known as the Humboldt University).
Related Topics:
1833 - University of Bonn - Law - Berlin - Humboldt University
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx and the Young Hegelians
In Berlin, Marx's interests turned to philosophy, much to his father's dismay, and he joined the circle of students and young professors known as the "Young Hegelians", led by Bruno Bauer. Some members of this circle drew an analogy between post-Aristotelian philosophy and post-Hegelian philosophy. Another Young Hegelian, Max Stirner, applied Hegelian criticism and argued that stopping anywhere short of nihilistic egoism was mysticism. His views were not accepted by most of his colleagues, and Karl Marx responded in parts of Die Deutsche Ideologie (The German Ideology), but decided not to publish it. Nevertheless Stirner's book was the main reason Marx abandoned the Feuerbachian view and developed the basic concept of historical materialism.
Related Topics:
Philosophy - Young Hegelians - Bruno Bauer - Aristotelian - Max Stirner - Nihilistic - Egoism - Mysticism - The German Ideology - Feuerbach - Historical materialism
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Georg Hegel died in 1831, and during his lifetime was an extremely influential figure at Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität and in German academia in general. The Hegelian establishment (known as the Right Hegelians) in place at Friedrich-Wilhelms maintained that the series of historical dialectics had been completed, and that Prussian society as it existed was the culmination of all social development to date, with an extensive civil service system, good universities, industrialization, and high employment. The Young Hegelians with whom Marx was associated believed that there were still further dialectical changes to come, and that the Prussian society of the time was far from perfect as it still contained some pockets of poverty, government sponsored censorship and discrimination against non-Lutherans.
Related Topics:
Georg Hegel - 1831 - Right Hegelians - Dialectics - Civil service - Industrialization - Employment - Lutherans
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx was told not to submit his doctoral dissertation at the Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität, as it would certainly be poorly received there due to his reputation as a Young Hegelian radical. Marx instead submitted his dissertation, which compared the atomic theories of Democritus and Epicurus, to the University of Jena in 1840, where it was accepted.
Related Topics:
Doctoral dissertation - Democritus - Epicurus - University of Jena - 1840
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Career
When his mentor Bruno Bauer was dismissed from the philosophy faculty in 1842, Marx abandoned philosophy for journalism and went on to edit the Rheinische Zeitung, a radical Cologne newspaper. After the newspaper was shut in 1843, in part due to Marx's conflicts with government censors, Marx returned to philosophy, turned to political activism, and made his living as a freelance journalist. Marx soon moved, however, something he would do often as a result of his views.
Related Topics:
1842 - Journalism - Rheinische Zeitung - Cologne - 1843 - Freelance journalist
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx first moved to France, where he re-evaluated his relationship with Bauer and the Young Hegelians, and wrote On the Jewish Question, mostly a critique of current notions of civil rights and political emancipation. It was in Paris that he met and began working with his life-long close friend and collaborator Friedrich Engels, a theorist and (in years to come) a committed Communist, who called Marx's attention to the situation of the working class and guided Marx's interest in economics. After he was forced to leave Paris for his writings, he and Engels moved to Brussels, Belgium.
Related Topics:
France - On the Jewish Question - Critique - Civil rights - Emancipation - Paris - Friedrich Engels - Working class - Economics - Brussels - Belgium
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
There they co-wrote The German Ideology, a critique of the philosophy of Hegel and the Young Hegelians. Marx next wrote The Poverty of Philosophy (1847), a critique of French socialist thought. These works laid the foundation for Marx and Engels' most famous work, The Communist Manifesto, first published on February 21, 1848, which was commissioned by the Communist League (formerly, the League of the Just), an organization of German émigrés whom Marx had coveted in London.
Related Topics:
The German Ideology - Young Hegelians - The Poverty of Philosophy - 1847 - The Communist Manifesto - February 21 - 1848 - Communist League - London
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
That year Europe experienced revolutionary upheaval; a working-class movement seized power from King Louis Philippe in France and invited Marx to return to Paris. When this government collapsed in 1849, Marx moved back to Cologne and restarted the Rheinische Zeitung, only to be swiftly expelled again. Marx's final move was to London. In 1852 Marx wrote his famous pamphlet The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, in which he analyzed Napoleon III's takeover of France. From 1852 to 1861, while in London, Marx contributed to Horace Greeley's New York Tribune as its European correspondent.
Related Topics:
Europe - Louis Philippe - 1849 - 1852 - The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte - Napoleon III's - 1861 - Horace Greeley - New York Tribune
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
First International and Gladstone quote
In 1863, Chancellor of the Exchequer William Ewart Gladstone gave a budget speech to Parliament in which he commented on the increase in the United Kingdom's national wealth, and added (according to the report of the speech in The Times), "I should look almost with apprehension and with pain upon this intoxicating augmentation of wealth and power if it were my belief that it was confined to the class who are in easy circumstances. This takes no cognizance at all of the condition of the laboring population. The augmentation I have described and which is founded, I think, upon accurate returns, is an augmentation entirely confined to classes possessed of property." But, in the semi-official version published in Hansard, Gladstone deleted the final sentence (editing the Hansard version was a common practice among Members of Parliament).
Related Topics:
1863 - Chancellor of the Exchequer - William Ewart Gladstone - Parliament - United Kingdom - The Times - Hansard - Members of Parliament
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
In 1864 Marx organized the International Workingmen's Association, later called the First International, as a base for continued political activism. In his inaugural address, he purported to quote Gladstone's speech, to the effect that, "This intoxicating augmentation of wealth and power is entirely confined to classes of property." He repeated the citation in Volume 1 of Capital. The discrepancy between Marx's quote and the Hansard version of the speech (which was well-known) was soon employed in an attempt to discredit the International. Marx attempted to rebut the accusations of dishonesty, but the allegation continued to resurface. Marx later gave as his source the newspaper The Morning Star.
Related Topics:
1864 - International Workingmen's Association - First International - Political activism - The Morning Star
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Engels devoted a good deal of attention to the affair in the preface to the fourth edition of Capital — which, likewise, did not put the matter to rest. Engels claimed that it was not The Morning Star but The Times that Marx was following. Indeed, critics of Marxism such as the journalist Paul Johnson continue to invoke Marx's supposed misquotation as evidence of general dishonesty. One can find a straightforward unravelling of this dispute in David A. Felix's work, Marx As Politician (London, 1983).
Related Topics:
Paul Johnson - David A. Felix
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The International survived the controversy, however, collapsing in 1872 in part because of the fall of the Paris Commune, and in part because many members turned to Mikhail Bakunin's anarchism. In London throughout this period, Marx also dedicated himself to the historical and theoretical research behind Das Kapital (Capital: A Critique of Political Economy). Marx published the first volume in 1867. The remaining two volumes of Capital were never completed by Marx, but were reconstructed by Engels from extensive notes and drafts, and published posthumously.
Related Topics:
1872 - Paris Commune - Mikhail Bakunin - Anarchism - Das Kapital - 1867 - Posthumously
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marital life
Marx's wife, born Jenny von Westphalen, came from an aristocratic background. Their engagement was secret at first, and for several years it was opposed by both families. Jenny's uncle was Lion Philips, father of the brothers Gerard and Anton who founded the famous Philips company in 1891. The Marxes had many children, several of whom died young — their daughter Eleanor (1855-1898), born in London, was also a committed socialist and helped edit her father's works. Jenny Marx died quickly in December 1881.
Related Topics:
Jenny von Westphalen - Engagement - Lion Philips - Gerard - Anton - Philips - Eleanor
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Later life
Throughout the later period of Marx's life he was generally impoverished and depended on financial contributions from Engels to help with his family's living expenses and debts. Marx died in London in the year 1883, and is buried in Highgate Cemetery, London. The message carved on Marx's tombstone - a monument built in 1954 by the British Communist Party - is: "Workers of all lands, unite". Marx's original tomb was humbly adorned.
Related Topics:
Highgate Cemetery - Tombstone - British Communist Party - Workers of all lands, unite
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Influences on Marx's thought
Marx's thought was strongly influenced by:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
- the dialectical historicism of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel
- the classical political economy of Adam Smith and David Ricardo.
- French socialist and sociological thought.
Marx believed that he could study history and society scientifically and discern tendencies of history and the resulting outcome of social conflicts. Some followers of Marx concluded, therefore, that a communist revolution is inevitable. However, Marx famously asserted that "philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point however is to change it", and he clearly dedicated himself to trying to alter the world. Consequently, most followers of Marx are not fatalists, but activists who believe that revolutionaries must organize social change.
Related Topics:
History - Society - Revolution - Social change
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx's view of history, which came to be called the materialist interpretation of history (and which was developed further as the philosophy of dialectical materialism) is certainly influenced by Hegel's claim that reality (and history) should be viewed dialectically, through a clash of opposing forces. Hegel believed that the direction of human history is characterized in the movement from the fragmentary toward the complete and the real (which was also a movement towards greater and greater rationality). Sometimes, Hegel explained, this progressive unfolding of the Absolute involves gradual, evolutionary accretion but at other times requires discontinuous, revolutionary leaps — episodal upheavals against the existing status quo. While Marx accepted this broad conception of history, Hegel was an idealist, and Marx sought to rewrite dialectics in materialist terms. He wrote that Hegelianism stood the movement of reality on its head, and that it was necessary to set it upon its feet.
Related Topics:
Materialist interpretation of history - Dialectical materialism - Dialectically - Rationality - The Absolute - Status quo - Idealist - Materialist
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx's acceptance of this notion of materialist dialectics which rejected Hegel's idealism was greatly influenced by Ludwig Feuerbach. In The Essence of Christianity, Feuerbach argued that God is really a creation of man and that the qualities people attribute to God are really qualities of humanity. Accordingly, Marx argued that it is the material world that is real and that our ideas of it are consequences, not causes, of the world. Thus, like Hegel and other philosophers, Marx distinguished between appearances and reality. But he did not believe that the material world hides from us the "real" world of the ideal; on the contrary, he thought that historically and socially specific ideologies prevented people from seeing the material conditions of their lives clearly.
Related Topics:
Ludwig Feuerbach - The Essence of Christianity - God - Humanity - Ideologies
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The other important contribution to Marx's revision of Hegelianism was Engels' book, The Condition of the Working Class in England in 1844, which led Marx to conceive of the historical dialectic in terms of class conflict and to see the modern working class as the most progressive force for revolution.
Related Topics:
The Condition of the Working Class in England in 1844 - Class conflict - Working class
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx's philosophy
As the reputable American Marx scholar Hal Draper remarked, there are few thinkers in modern history whose thought has been so badly misrepresented, by Marxists and anti-Marxists alike. Indeed, shortly before his death, Marx himself said, in response to so-called 'marxists' who supported reform instead of revolution, something to the effect of "if that is Marxism, then I am not a Marxist". Subsequently, the merger of Marxist thought with Leninism, forming the official state ideology (Marxism-Leninism) of the Soviet bloc, arguably departed further from Marx's own beliefs and analyses. However, following the 1989-91 collapse of the Soviet bloc, there has been a return by non-Marxists to Marx's own writing, in particular for insights in his analysis of capitalism that are still relevant today.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The notion of labour is fundamental in Marx's thought. Basically, Marx argued that it is human nature to transform nature, and he calls this process of transformation "labour" and the capacity to transform nature labour power. For Marx, this is a natural capacity for a physical activity, but it is intimately tied to the human mind and human imagination:
Related Topics:
Labour - Human nature - Labour power
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
:A spider conducts operations that resemble those of a weaver, and a bee puts to shame many an architect in the construction of her cells. But what distinguishes the worst architect from the best of bees is this, that the architect raises his structure in imagination before he erects it in reality. (Capital, Vol. I, Chap. 7, Pt. 1)
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Karl Marx inherits that Hegelian dialectic and, with it, a disdain for the notion of an underlying invariant human nature. Sometimes Marxists express their views by contrasting ?nature? with ?history?. Sometimes they use the phrase ?existence precedes consciousness?. The point, in either case, is that who a person is, is determined by where and when he is — social context takes precedence over innate behavior; or, in other words, one of the main features of human nature is adaptability.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx did not believe that all people worked the same way, or that how one works is entirely personal and individual. Instead, he argued that work is a social activity and that the conditions and forms under and through which people work are socially determined and change over time.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx's analysis of history is based on his distinction between the means / forces of production, literally those things, such as land, natural resources, and technology, that are necessary for the production of material goods, and the relations of production, in other words, the social and technical relationships people enter into as they acquire and use the means of production. Together these comprise the mode of production; Marx observed that within any given society the mode of production changes, and that European societies had progressed from a feudal mode of production to a capitalist mode of production. In general, Marx believed that the means of production change more rapidly than the relations of production (for example, we develop a new technology, such as the Internet, and only later do we develop laws to regulate that technology). For Marx this mismatch between (economic) base and (social) superstructure is a major source of social disruption and conflict.
Related Topics:
Means / forces of production - Relations of production - Mode of production - Feudal - Capitalist - Technology - Internet - Superstructure
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx understood the "social relations of production" to comprise not only relations among individuals, but between or among groups of people, or classes. As a scientist and materialist, Marx did not understand classes as purely subjective (in other words, groups of people who consciously identified with one another). He sought to define classes in terms of objective criteria, such as their access to resources. For Marx, different classes have divergent interests, which is another source of social disruption and conflict.
Related Topics:
Production - Class - Scientist - Materialist - Subjective - Resources
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx was especially concerned with how people relate to that most fundamental resource of all, their own labour-power. Marx wrote extensively about this in terms of the problem of alienation. As with the dialectic, Marx began with a Hegelian notion of alienation but developed a more materialist conception. For Marx, the possibility that one may give up ownership of one's own labour — one's capacity to transform the world — is tantamount to being alienated from one's own nature; it is a spiritual loss. Marx described this loss in terms of commodity fetishism, in which people come to believe that it is the very things that they produce that are powerful, and the sources of power and creativity, rather than people themselves. He argued that when this happens, people begin to mediate all their relationships among themselves and with others through commodities.
Related Topics:
Labour-power - Alienation - Commodity fetishism
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Commodity fetishism is an example of what Engels called false consciousness, which is closely related to the understanding of ideology. By ideology they meant ideas that reflect the interests of a particular class at a particular time in history, but which are presented as universal and eternal. Marx and Engels' point was not only that such beliefs are at best half-truths; they serve an important political function. Put another way, the control that one class exercises over the means of production includes not only the production of food or manufactured goods; it includes the production of ideas as well (this provides one possible explanation for why members of a subordinate class may hold ideas contrary to their own interests). Thus, while such ideas may be false, they also reveal in coded form some truth about political relations. For example, although the belief that the things people produce are actually more productive than the people who produce them is literally absurd, it does reflect the fact (according to Marx and Engels) that people under capitalism are alienated from their own labour-power. Another example of this sort of analysis is Marx's understanding of religion, summed up in a passage from the Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right:
Related Topics:
Commodity fetishism - False consciousness - Ideology - Philosophy of Right
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
:Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Whereas his Gymnasium senior thesis argued that the primary social function of religion was to promote solidarity, here Marx sees the social function as a way of expressing and coping with social inequality, thereby maintaining the status quo.
Related Topics:
Gymnasium - Solidarity - Social inequality
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Critique of capitalism
Marx argued that this alienation of human work (and resulting commodity fetishism) is precisely the defining feature of capitalism. Prior to capitalism, markets existed in Europe where producers and merchants bought and sold commodities. According to Marx, a capitalist mode of production developed in Europe when labor itself became a commodity — when peasants became free to sell their own labor-power, and needed to do so because they no longer possessed their own land or tools necessary to produce. People sell their labor-power when they accept compensation in return for whatever work they do in a given period of time (in other words, they are not selling the product of their labor, but their capacity to work). In return for selling their labor power they receive money, which allows them to survive. Those who must sell their labor power to live are "proletarians." The person who buys the labor power, generally someone who does own the land and technology to produce, is a "capitalist" or "bourgeois." (Marx considered this an objective description of capitalism, distinct from any one of a variety of ideological claims of or about capitalism). The proletarians inevitably outnumber the capitalists.
Related Topics:
Capitalism - Capitalist mode of production - Proletarian - Bourgeois - Objective
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx distinguished industrial capitalists from merchant capitalists. Merchants buy goods in one place and sell them in another; more precisely, they buy things in one market and sell them in another. Since the laws of supply and demand operate within given markets, there is often a difference between the price of a commodity in one market and another. Merchants, then, practice arbitrage, and hope to capture the difference between these two markets. According to Marx, capitalists, on the other hand, take advantage of the difference between the labor market and the market for whatever commodity is produced by the capitalist. Marx observed that in practically every successful industry input unit-costs are lower than output unit-prices. Marx called the difference "surplus value" and argued that this surplus value had its source in surplus labour.
Related Topics:
Merchant - Goods - Supply and demand - Markets - Arbitrage - Surplus value - Surplus labour
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The capitalist mode of production is capable of tremendous growth because the capitalist can, and has an incentive to, reinvest profits in new technologies. Marx considered the capitalist class to be the most revolutionary in history, because it constantly revolutionized the means of production. But Marx argued that capitalism was prone to periodic crises. He suggested that over time, capitalists would invest more and more in new technologies, and less and less in labor. Since Marx believed that surplus value appropriated from labor is the source of profits, he concluded that the rate of profit would fall even as the economy grew. When the rate of profit falls below a certain point, the result would be a recession or depression in which certain sectors of the economy would collapse. Marx understood that during such a crisis the price of labor would also fall, and eventually make possible the investment in new technologies and the growth of new sectors of the economy.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx believed that this cycle of growth, collapse, and growth would be punctuated by increasingly severe crises. Moreover, he believed that the long-term consequence of this process was necessarily the enrichment and empowerment of the capitalist class and the impoverishment of the proletariat. He believed that were the proletariat to seize the means of production, they would encourage social relations that would benefit everyone equally, and a system of production less vulnerable to periodic crises. In general, Marx thought that peaceful negotiation of this problem was impracticable, and that a massive, well-organized and violent revolution was required by necessity. Finally, he theorized that to maintain the socialist system, a dictatorship of the proletariat - a period where the needs of the working-class will be the common deciding factor, not that of capital - must be established and maintained.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Critique of bourgeois democracy and of anti-Semitism
Some scholars have presented an alternative reading of Marx, primarily based on his essay On the Jewish Question. Economist Tyler Cowen, historian Marvin Perry, and political scientist Joshua Muravchik have suggested that what they see as an intense hatred for the "Jewish Class" was part of Marx's belief that if he could convince his contemporaries and the public to hate Jewish capitalists, the public would eventually come to hate non-Jewish capitalists as well.
Related Topics:
On the Jewish Question - Tyler Cowen - Marvin Perry - Joshua Muravchik
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Most scholars reject this claim for two reasons: first, it is based on two short essays written in the 1840s, and ignores the bulk of Marx's analysis of capitalism written in the following years. Second, it distorts the argument of On the Jewish Question, in which Marx deconstructs liberal notions of emancipation. During the Enlightenment, philosophers and political theorists argued that religious authority had been oppressing human beings, and that religion must be separated from the functions of the state for people to be truly free. Following the French Revolution, many people were thus calling for the emancipation of the Jews.
Related Topics:
1840 - Liberal - Emancipation - The Enlightenment - Religion - French Revolution - Emancipation of the Jews
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
At the same time, many argued that Christianity is a more enlightened and advanced religion than Judaism. For example, Marx's former mentor, Bruno Bauer, argued that Christians need to be emancipated only once (from Christianity), and Jews need to be emancipated twice — first from Judaism (presumably, by converting to Christianity), then from religion altogether.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx rejects Bauer's argument as a form of Christian ethnocentrism, if not anti-Semitic. Marx proceeds to turn Bauer's language, and the rhetoric of anti-Semites, upside down to make a more progressive argument. First, he points out that Bruno Bauer's argument is too parochial because it considers Christianity to be more evolved than Judaism, and because it narrowly defines the problem that requires emancipation to be religion. Marx instead argues that the issue is not religion, but capitalism. Pointing out that anti-Semitic stereotypes of Jews are fundamentally anti-capitalist, Marx provides a theory of anti-Semitism by suggesting that anti-Semites scapegoat Jews for capitalism because too many non-Jews benefit from, or are invested in capitalism, to attack capitalism directly.
Related Topics:
Ethnocentrism - Anti-Semitic - Anti-capitalist
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Marx also uses this rhetoric ironically to develop his critique of bourgeois notions of emancipation. Marx points out that the bourgeois notion of freedom is predicated on choice (in politics, through elections; in the economy, through the market), but that this form of freedom is anti-social and alienating. Although Bauer and other liberals believe that emancipation means freedom to choose, Marx argues that this is at best a very narrow notion of freedom. Thus, what Bauer believes would be the emancipation of the Jews is for Marx actually alienation, not emancipation. After explaining that he is not referring to real Jews or to the Jewish religion, Marx appropriates this anti-Semitic rhetoric against itself (in a way that parallels his Hegelian argument that capitalism contains the seeds of its own destruction) by using "Judaism" ironically as a metaphor for capitalism. In this sense, Marx states, all Europeans are "Jewish". This is a pun on two levels. First, if the Jews must be emancipated, Marx is saying that all Europeans must be emancipated. Second, if by "Judaism" one really means "capitalism," then far from Jews needing to be emancipated from Christianity (as Bauer called for), Christians need to be emancipated from Judaism (meaning, bourgeois society). See: works by historian Hal Draper and David McLellan. See also: .
Related Topics:
Rhetoric - Ironically - Freedom - Market - Hal Draper - David McLellan
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ Table of Content ~
| ► | Introduction |
| ► | Theiapolis People! |
| ► | Biography |
| ► | Marx's influence |
| ► | Contemporary criticism |
| ► | References |
| ► | See also |
| ► | External links |
| ► | Goodies & Collectibles |
| ► | Posters & Prints |
~ What's Hot ~
~ Community ~
| ► | History Forum Come and discuss about History, Civilizations, Historical Events and Figures |
| ► | History Web-Ring A community of sites, blogs and forums dedicated to History. Do not hesitate to submit your site. |
| ► | Theiapolis People! Latest people news, biographies, filmographies, photo gallery, message board. |
and are licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License.
Lexicon - Privacy Policy - Spiritus-Temporis.com ©2005.