Free software

:This article is about Free Software as defined by the sociopolitical Free Software movement; for information on software distributed without charge, see freeware. For other uses, see free software (disambiguation).

Free software controversies

The BitKeeper controversy in the free software movement illustrates the movement's major issues and points of view.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Larry McVoy invited high-profile free software projects to use BitKeeper to attract paying users. In 2002 a controversial decision was made to use BitKeeper, a proprietary software product, to develop the Linux kernel, a free software project. The excerpt below illustrates why this proved to be a major source of controversy.

Related Topics:
Larry McVoy - BitKeeper

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

:"McVoy made the program available gratis to free software developers. This did not mean it was free software for them: they were privileged not to part with their money, but they still had to part with their freedom. They gave up the fundamental freedoms that define free software: freedom to run the program as you wish for any purpose, freedom to study and change the source code as you wish, freedom to make and redistribute copies, and freedom to publish modified versions.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

:The Free Software Movement has said "Think of free speech, not free beer" for 15 years. McVoy said the opposite; he invited developers to focus on the lack of monetary price, instead of on freedom. A free software activist would dismiss this suggestion, but those in our community who value technical advantage above freedom and community were susceptible to it. ...

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

:A free kernel, even a whole free operating system, is not sufficient to use your computer in freedom; we need free software for everything else, too. Free applications, free drivers, free BIOS: some of those projects face large obstacles -- the need to reverse engineer formats or protocols or pressure companies to document them, or to work around or face down patent threats, or to compete with a network effect. Success will require firmness and determination. A better kernel is desirable, to be sure, but not at the expense of weakening the impetus to liberate the rest of the software world." http://software.newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=05/04/25/130207

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

McVoy withdrew permission for gratis use by free software projects. Many in the free software movement see the whole affair as a vindication of Richard Stallman's principled position over the more utilitarian approach of Linus Torvalds.

Related Topics:
Richard Stallman - Linus Torvalds

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~